The Audi A4 question keeps coming up in my inbox.
"Should I buy one?" "Are they reliable now?" "What's the real cost of ownership?"
Let me tell you why I think the A4 is still relevant. And why some people are completely wrong about it.
Here's what happened.
BMW got boring with the 3 Series. Mercedes made the C-Class too complicated. And Audi?
They quietly perfected the A4 while nobody…
The Audi A4 question keeps coming up in my inbox.
“Should I buy one?” “Are they reliable now?” “What’s the real cost of ownership?”
Let me tell you why I think the A4 is still relevant. And why some people are completely wrong about it.
Here’s what happened.
BMW got boring with the 3 Series. Mercedes made the C-Class too complicated. And Audi?
They quietly perfected the A4 while nobody was watching.
The current B9 generation isn’t just good. It’s the car that made me understand why Audi sells so many of them.
Build Quality That Actually Lasts:
Technology That Makes Sense:
But here’s the thing nobody mentions. The A4 isn’t trying to be everything to everyone anymore. It knows exactly what it is.
I’ve had three different A4s over the years. Here’s what actually matters day-to-day.
Morning Commute: The 2.0 TFSI engine wakes up properly. No more of that laggy, cold-start nonsense from the old days. The cabin’s quiet enough for phone calls. The seats don’t leave you aching after an hour.
Weekend Duties: Boot space that swallows a week’s shopping. Rear seats where adults can actually sit. Fuel economy that won’t bankrupt you.
The Honest Downsides:
The Reality: It’s adequate. Nothing more, nothing less. Good for company car drivers who care about benefit-in-kind rates.
Who It’s For:
The Sweet Spot: This is the one most people should buy. Enough power for motorway overtaking. Reasonable fuel economy. Best balance of cost vs. capability.
Real-World Performance:
The Enthusiast Choice: Properly quick. Makes the right noises. Quattro all-wheel drive is standard.
The Catch: Fuel economy drops to the low 30s. Insurance jumps significantly. You’ll want the sports suspension (which costs extra).
Diesel (40 TDI): Still makes sense for high-mileage drivers. 60+ mpg on long runs. Torque delivery that feels effortless.
But:
Petrol (40 TFSI): Smoother, quieter, and more refined. No DPF worries. Better for mixed driving.
My Take: Unless you’re doing 20k+ miles annually, go petrol. The 40 TFSI is sweet enough for most needs.
What’s Included:
What’s Missing:
The Popular Choice:
Reality Check: The suspension is too firm for British roads. The wheels bend if you look at a pothole wrong. But it looks the part.
The Full Fat Option: Everything you can imagine. Massage seats, premium audio, and adaptive suspension.
The Problem: Costs more than a BMW 330i M Sport. Depreciation hits harder. Half the features you’ll never use.
Tires: 18-inch wheels mean £150+ per tire. 19-inch wheels (on S Line Plus) mean £200+ per corner. Budget £800+ annually if you drive normally.
Servicing: Variable servicing intervals sound good on paper. In reality, 18-20k mile services stress the engine. Independent specialists charge £300-500 per service. Main dealers want £600+.
Insurance: Group ratings are reasonable. But the S Line tax is real. Same car, different trim, £200+ more per year.
What’s Reliable:
What Goes Wrong:
The Bottom Line: Modern A4s are reliable if maintained properly. But “properly” means following Audi’s schedule religiously.
Best Years: 2018 onwards (post-facelift models). Better engines, fewer electrical gremlins.
What to Pay:
Mileage Sweet Spot: 40k-70k miles. Low enough to avoid major issues. High enough to avoid the depreciation cliff.
Service History: Must be complete. Audi main dealer preferred. Independent specialists are acceptable if reputable.
Common Issues to Check:
A4 Wins: Better interior quality. More comfortable ride. Superior infotainment system.
3 Series Wins: Better driving dynamics. Stronger resale values. More engaging to drive.
A4 Wins: More reliable electronics. Better real-world fuel economy. Simpler to live with.
C-Class Wins: More luxurious interior. Better ride comfort. Stronger brand cachet.
Here’s my honest take.
Buy if:
Don’t Buy if:
Q: Is the Audi A4 reliable? A: Modern A4s (2018+) are generally reliable. Service history is everything. Budget for carbon cleaning on petrol engines every 60k miles.
Q: Should I buy an A4 with petrol or diesel? A: Petrol unless you’re doing 20k+ miles annually. The 2.0 TFSI is smooth, refined, and trouble-free when maintained.
Q: What’s the best A4 engine? A: 40 TFSI (190 hp) petrol for most buyers. Good balance of performance and economy. Avoid the base 35 TFSI unless the budget is tight.
Q: Are A4 parts expensive? A: Yes, but not ridiculously so. Independent specialists charge reasonable rates. Avoid main dealers for routine maintenance.
Q: Should I buy new or used? A: Used, unless you’re keeping it 5+ years. 2-3-year-old cars offer the best value. Let someone else take the depreciation hit.
Q: Is Quattro worth having? A: In the UK? Absolutely. The confidence in wet/winter conditions is worth the small MPG penalty. Only comes on higher-spec models, though.
Q: What about the A4 Avant estate? A: More practical, same running costs, slightly worse handling. Perfect if you need the boot space. Holds value better too.
Look, the A4 isn’t perfect.
It’s not the most exciting car to drive. It’s not the cheapest to run. It’s not the most spacious in its class.
But here’s what it is: A thoroughly competent, well-built, comfortable executive saloon that does everything well without any major flaws.
Sometimes that’s exactly what you need.
If you want drama, buy something else. If you want dependable quality that won’t embarrass you in the company car park, the Audi A4 delivers exactly that.
Just make sure you buy the right one.
Need more executive salon advice? Check out our guides on [German luxury car ownership], [executive car running costs], and [premium saloon comparisons].